Illustration by tuput
English
Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana: Part 1 opened on 5 November 2026 with effects by DNEG. Sacnilk's roundup of 19 critic reviews lists VFX among the praised elements, and reviewers in India and the Gulf singled out the Pushpak Vimana and Jatayu sequences. Some also found seams, which this piece records by name.
Sacnilk, the Indian box-office tracker that also compiles critic scores, had 19 reviews of Nitesh Tiwari’s film Ramayana: Part 1 in its roundup on 9 November 2026. It classed 14 as positive and 5 as mixed, with none negative, and an average of 75 out of 100. Those labels rate the whole film. The same page also has a list of what critics praised, and visual effects (VFX) is on it, next to performances, direction and cinematography.
This article collects what named critics wrote about the effects specifically. The film is a screen retelling of the Valmiki Ramayana by Tiwari, producer Namit Malhotra and their team, with effects by the studio DNEG. It opened in India on 5 November 2026, runs 195 minutes, and the English-language release is titled Ramayana: Rise of a Legend. For the story the film retells, see what the Ramayana is.
The praise, outlet by outlet
Ankit Ojha of The National, in the UAE, gave the film four stars out of five on 5 November. He wrote that it has “some of the best visual effects and action choreography seen in Indian cinema”. He tied that to the producers’ record, since Malhotra leads both Prime Focus Studios and DNEG, and he said many effects-heavy Indian films had struggled to make their digital worlds convincing.
Somya Mehta of Khaleej Times, also published on 5 November, wrote that the film reaches “a level of cinematic craftsmanship rarely, if ever, witnessed in Indian cinema”. She also wrote that its sequences can hold their own against the more ambitious Hollywood productions.
Aishani Biswas of Outlook India gave the film 2.5 out of 5, a mixed score overall. On the effects she was direct: “The film’s greatest achievement is its visual world.” She called the VFX immersive and said the environments have a grandeur that Indian cinema about the epics has often struggled to achieve.
Priyanka Roy of t2online wrote that the film “unanimously scores well” in the effects department and singled out the 3D work, which she ranked among the best she had seen recently. Gautam Anand of The Cinemaholic, rating it 3.5 out of 5, called the film a winner on effects “from beginning to end”. He thought the production design and cinematography were as good.
The Guardian’s review is listed by Sacnilk at four stars out of five from Peter Bradshaw, under a headline calling it a spectacular, huge-scale epic. Gulf News, on 5 November, also reported the four-star rating. This piece does not quote the Guardian’s text, which could not be opened.
The sequences reviewers named
Three scenes recur. The first is the aerial fight between Ravana and the bird Jatayu, which the Ramayana tells of in the abduction of Sita. Khaleej Times called its visual construction one of the film’s most memorable moments. Anand wrote that it is “one of the most imaginative uses of visual effects” he had seen that year. Shilajit Mitra of Hollywood Reporter India, in a feature published on 6 November, named it the most impressive sequence of Part 1. He said the first glimpse of the Pushpak Vimana, Ravana’s flying vehicle, is a giant twirling orb, and that the skin textures and movement in the fight have a solidity and photorealism.
The second is the Pushpak Vimana itself. Khaleej Times gave it a special mention, and Roy called it exquisitely designed.
The third is the scene of Ravana’s ten heads. Mitra noted that a 1961 Hindi film, Sampoorna Ramayana, showed the heads through superimposition, and that DNEG here sent the camera into Ravana’s left eye and into a dark, weightless space where ten versions of him, of different ages, argue. He called it inventive.
How the effects were planned, as the makers tell it
Two crew interviews, both with Variety India, explain what the critics were looking at. Cinematographer Pankaj Kumar said on 8 September 2026 that every shot had been pre-visualized with motion capture, which means the scenes were animated in a virtual set before shooting, and that the VFX team knew which environment each angle needed. He added that most backgrounds were blue screen and that the crew built fragments of sets, not full ones.
Production designer Subrata Chakraborty said on 12 November 2026 that the Ayodhya throne room was about 70 percent physically built, the fight in Lanka about 30 percent, and the Pushpak Vimana only about 10 percent. His aim, he said, was for viewers to be “unable to tell what was set and what was VFX”. These are the filmmakers’ own accounts and no outside audit of them was found. DNEG’s own announcement describes a film made for IMAX with DNEG and ReDefine as VFX partners, and DNEG’s page says the studio has won eight Academy Awards for Best VFX since 2011.
Where critics saw seams
The dissent is specific. Ojha wrote that scenes in newly conquered Lanka struggle to blend crowds convincingly, though he said such dips were few. Swathi P Ajith of Onmanorama wrote that the effects work well in the film’s landscapes, but that in the second half some computer-made characters look “noticeably artificial and occasionally cartoonish”.
Puja Talwar of The Federal called the effects by and large impressive and the technical ambition evident, while noting that some portions look artificial or overly computer-generated. Mitra made a similar point about creature design, writing that the Asuras in other sequences are less convincing than the Jatayu fight. Mehta wrote that the digital forests sometimes lack the feel of a real one, and that the long battle against Surpanakha’s forces felt overstretched. Rahul Desai of Hollywood Reporter India noted uneven lighting on faces against computer-made scenery, and said it did not damage the broader picture.
Several reviews put their reservations elsewhere. Outlook, Onmanorama and Hollywood Reporter India wrote that the emotional depth did not match the scale of the visuals, and The Cinemaholic and The Federal found the score a weak point. Sacnilk’s list of criticised elements names pacing and length, the music and emotional resonance.
The trailer row that came first
The film’s effects were being argued over before anyone saw the finished version. After a first look at Ranbir Kapoor as Rama circulated online, Onmanorama reported on 8 April 2026 that viewers had called some effects underwhelming. Malhotra answered with a note on social media, which Onmanorama says did not name specific complaints but said the team was paying close attention and refining the film, with thousands of artists involved.
The trailer was released on 30 July 2026. On 12 August, Outlook reported, drawing on an interview with Collider, that Malhotra said the effects were not yet complete and that viewers were judging them on phones. Tiwari said some sequences had taken between two and a half and three years. Reviewers who saw the finished film on screen rated the effects mostly as a strength, as the quotations above show.
A director’s verdict
S. S. Rajamouli, the director of Baahubali and RRR, posted on X after seeing the film, according to Open magazine on 6 November. Open reported that he wrote that the scale of the film and its visuals on the big screen are “spectacular to watch”, and that he congratulated Tiwari, Malhotra and the team.
Sources & further reading
- Sacnilk: Ramayana Review of Reviews, updated 9 November 2026
- The National, 5 November 2026: Ramayana review (Ankit Ojha)
- Khaleej Times, 5 November 2026: Ramayana review (Somya Mehta)
- Outlook India, 5 November 2026: Ramayana review (Aishani Biswas)
- The Federal, 5 November 2026: Ramayana: Part One review (Puja Talwar)
- Onmanorama, 5 November 2026: Ramayana Part 1 review (Swathi P Ajith)
- The Cinemaholic, 6 November 2026: Ramayana Part 1 review (Gautam Anand)
- t2online, 5 November 2026: Ramayana Part 1 review (Priyanka Roy)
- Hollywood Reporter India, 5 November 2026: Ramayana review (Rahul Desai)
- Hollywood Reporter India, 6 November 2026: five standout sequences (Shilajit Mitra)
- Open magazine, 6 November 2026: Ramayana Part One opening report with S. S. Rajamouli's post
- Gulf News, 5 November 2026: Ramayana box office and early reviews (Lakshana N Palat)
- DNEG: The first look at Ramayana (company announcement)
- DNEG: About DNEG (company page, Academy Award count)
- Onmanorama, 8 April 2026: After VFX backlash, Ramayana producer promises major fixes
- Outlook India, 12 August 2026: Ranbir Kapoor, Namit Malhotra and Nitesh Tiwari on the trailer's VFX
- Variety India, 8 September 2026: cinematographer Pankaj Kumar on pre-visualization with motion capture
- Variety India, 12 November 2026: production designer Subrata Chakraborty on blending sets and VFX
Researched and written with the help of AI tools and edited for accuracy. Provided for general information and discussion only, not professional advice. See our editorial standards and disclaimer. Spotted an error? Tell us.
Enjoyed this? Get the next one.
One good read at a time, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.